Posted by: eyespie1 | August 2, 2010

The Missing Resident’s Petition

The Chief Executive of the ERY Council, Mr Nigel Pearson, may never have seen the first petition handed-into the Council Offices in 2009, signed by over 400 Swinemoor residents against the building of a new hospital on the Swinemoor Lane, but we now know that it was never considered or even mentioned at the ERY Council’s Outline planning Committee in September 2009. Since the residents became aware of this in October 2009 and despite reports of this ‘missing’ petition in the local press, no written explanation, no apology, nothing, has been sent to this large group of Swinemoor residents, whose opinions continue to be ignored and the true strength of feeling from the locals, covered-up by propaganda from a group of individuals who attend the Community Hospital Liaison Committee meetings. Despite them being notified in November 2009 of the petition’s existence and of the opposition to building a hospital on this site, this information (and despite repeated requests) has still not been included on the Committee’s minutes. Of course, they must continue to maintain that the public have been fully engaged at each stage of the planning process and that they support this hospital and of course a local resident’s petition proves otherwise.

Despite our questions being put to the Council’s planning department, a verbal response only was provided, i,e, that some enquiries were made with the front line staff, and that “the petition must have been handed-in too early”.

Even our MP, Mr Stuart ignores us and the respondents on his own blog!

Unless Mr N. Pearson does not read his local press, he cannot have missed reading about these residents’ frustrations and yet, the second petition, duly handed-in on 18th June 2010 (receipt requested and obtained) and marked for his attention, has still not been acknowledged as having been received, albeit, we see that it appears on the Planning website. Now what, Mr Pearson? We have heard nothing from you – again!

NOTICE to be sent to all ERY Councillors

We are therefore now bringing this matter to the attention of ALL the Councillors, to ensure that the Swinemoor resident’s views will indeed be considered at the Reserved Matters meeting, despite this item not being included in their Reserved Matters items for discussion.  In this, we are citing the Local Authorities (Petitions) (England) order 2010, which came into force on 15th June 2010 and we argue that this is not an Excluded matter, i.e. matter relating to a planning decision, (see ref: Citation, commencement, interpretation and application – 2) because there was a ‘systematic failure by the planning department in discharge of their functions’,( ref. Citation, commencement, etc.. 3)  by not hearing/considering/or acknowledging the resident’s views prior to or during the Outline Planning Council meeting of September 2009 and which could have produced a different decision.

We now intend to ensure that this matter is drawn to the attention of ALL Councillors, prior to Council meetings on 9th and 12th August, by sending them the following link to our NSH (noswinemoorhospital) blog site,

We hope that this time, the resident’s wishes will be fully considered.

Sent from Members of The No Swinemoor Hospital Campaign Group, which includes the Swinemoor Estate Residents Group

NSH’s  Quote: “When complaints are freely heard, deeply  considered and speedily reformed, then is the utmost bound of civil liberty attained that wise men look for” John Milton, 1644


  1. […] In Figure 1 you can see the rough route of the new Southern Relief Road is shown in red. This needs to run across low-lying, flood-prone land and cross the railway to reach the A1174. It is this road that is currently being built at a cost of £22m. Where is the traffic that will use this new road likely to come from? Is it from the West side of the town? Unlikely, most traffic from this side of the town will still go through the town centre to reach Aldi, Wickes or the Folly on the Lane. The North and East sides are relatively unaffected in terms of traffic flow. What about traffic from Hull? If they wish to reach the new developments proposed at Flemingate and Grovehill as well as the existing development on Swinemoor Lane, then they will use the Hull Road, A1174. This only leaves traffic from the Southwest side of the town, i.e the Lincoln Way, Poplars Way and Normandy Avenue areas.  Seems like a lot of money is being spent to benefit a relatively small proportion of the population and no credence at all has been given to the residents of the Swinemoor area – no change there then! […]

  2. […] this is a bit rich as Cllr Harold is a member the East Riding of Yorkshire Council: a council that ‘lost’ a petition signed by many of her constituents fighting against the construction of Swinemoor Hospital on a […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: